Just
as it is vital to know when and why to buy a mutual fund, it is equally
as important for investors to understand when it may be time to sell.
As the market fluctuates and the funds in which you invest change, as
may your financial needs and goals, navigating and timing fund sales
can be challenging.
One thing is for sure, selling is much more difficult than buying. Investors
typically make the mistake of overreacting and hastily selling on a little
bad news. Alternatively, investors can also suffer from paralysis that
prevents them from selling losing investments because they are reluctant
to admit they made a mistake or because of their narrow focus on recovering
their original investment.
Following are some tips for weighing your reasons to sell, aiming to help
you better recognize when it is time to say goodbye and hopefully improve
your long-term position in the market. Remember, selling a mutual fund
may result in a taxable capital gain or loss. However, selling a fund in
an IRA or qualified plan would generally not be a taxable event. Please
consult your tax advisor when making sell decisions.
1. Consider selling if it doesn’t belong in your asset allocation
plan — The bottom line is that you cannot make an intelligent investment
decision without a financial plan that is specifically tailored to your
personal goals, timeframe and risk tolerance. The heart of a good plan
is proper asset allocation. Remember that a fund may be doing a good job
for you but if your needs and risk tolerance change over time, you must
reinvest and rebalance your capital to meet those needs. When rebalancing
periodically, typically done at least once annually, you may need to sell
funds with superior recent performance, which may be emotionally challenging.
However, it may help to think of it as locking in your profits and a mechanical
way to force yourself to follow the old adage of “buy low, sell high.” While
it is always tempting to let your “winners” ride, that’s
how people end up with two-thirds of their portfolios in one fund when
the bubble bursts and end up big “losers” over the long term.
2. Consider selling if the management changes — Simply stated, a
mutual fund is only as good as the person whose job it is to pick the stocks.
While a five-star track record of a fund may look impressive, the manager
who’s responsible for that record may no longer be on the case. If
you invest in actively managed funds, you or your financial advisor should
focus on the current manager’s track record. Has he been successful
at other mutual funds? Were those funds similar to the one he’s heading
up now? Even if you didn’t buy a fund from the fund manager, turmoil
at the firm may be a good reason to get out. If a number of key people
leave, there may be more to follow, and the quality of management is likely
to dip.
3. Consider selling consistent underperformers — Poor short-term
performance may not be a good reason to sell a fund. (In fact, it might
even be a good reason to buy additional shares.) However, if a fund persists
in lagging over the longer term, anything over three years, it is worth
reconsidering. Remember that if you own an index fund, this doesn’t
apply because your objective is to capture the market, not exceed it. However,
if you’re paying for active management, there’s no reason you
should put up with extended sub-par performance. However, before cutting
the fund loose, be sure that you are comparing your underperformer to an
appropriate benchmark, such as its Morningstar category or a suitable index.
If your fund consistently underperforms its peer group and broader market
indexes, finding a better pick may be the way to go.
4. Consider selling if you can get a tax break — If your fund account
is in the red, it may make sense for you to sell and take a loss you can
use to offset future taxable gains. Capital losses are used to offset capital
gains, plus an additional $3,000 of capital losses can offset ordinary
income — which is often taxed at a higher rate than capital gains.
And capital losses that exceed the $3,000 threshold may be carried forward
indefinitely. (Before you make any moves or sales, make sure you consult
with your tax advisor).
5. Consider selling if the fund is tax-inefficient — Some funds have
portfolio turnover rates of 400 percent or more. That generates high trading
costs (which will be invisible but still payable by you) and potential
capital gains distributions even though you leave the money invested. Sometimes
very high turnover is a necessary but expensive part of a strategy, but
you need to know how costly it is and why you are tolerating it, if you
chose to do so.
6. Consider selling if expenses are too high — In choosing from among
similar fixed-income funds, expenses are one of the most important things
that separate the leaders from those that lag. Consider selling funds that
raise their expenses, unless taxes or back-end commissions dictate otherwise.
This is a red flag that indicates shareholders’ interest could be
taking a back seat.
Remember that a qualified financial advisor can help you create a comprehensive
financial plan which includes recommendations for buying and selling funds
and periodic rebalancing to help you best reach your long-term financial
goals.
This information is provided for informational purposes only. The information
is intended to be generic in nature and should not be applied or relied
upon in any particular situation without the advice of your tax, legal
and/or your financial advisor. The views expressed may not be suitable
for every situation.